I know this was posted a long time ago but I feel I have to comment.
In my opinion Ste Bell you are correct and Gurre you are wrong plain and simple.
Here are my reasons:
- Nerves send signals to your brain telling us there is a problem. By killing or temp killing these nerves we don't know if there is a problem or not. For training I can see Gurre your point; however, regarding living your life that is a different story entirely.
To debate this I'll look at the other side. No nerves equals no pain; this is great. I just broke my tibia and I don't know it. I can keep fighting so what is the problem? I don't hurt any.
I see a real problem here. Dude we just broke a bone and don't even know. Long term affects are greater potential for arthritis or other issues down the road.
Here is a true example. I am 33 years old now in 2008. I have studied the below styles. Yes before I get a number of comments no I never leveled to black belt. I had no desire to. I really did this for fun and to stay active. I don’t compete any longer I just box now for fun in my basement with my heavy bag, speed bag and slip bag while trying to ignore my wife’s nagging
To make a long story short I have the highest pain tolerance level you’ll ever find. I’m not bragging it’s just a fact and I would gladly give it back if I could. Currently I have a level 3 sprain and a torn tendon in my driving foot. The entire foot is black and blue not just part of it. I can put full pressure on it and still walk. I don’t because I know this is bad so I use crutches. In any case when I did do kung fu my Si-Fu taught pressure points. I don’t feel them at all so he never really used me as an example. One day he did. He used the pressure point right under my arm pit. I felt nothing. Picked another student and down they went in a second. This is good right? WRONG! Two days later I had the black and blue markings you would have though I was hit by a car.
Tore my roator cuf and dislocated it and did not even know till I started to feel a little discomfet.
Case in point just because you don’t feel pain does not mean you are not obtaining damage
choi la foot kung fu = Blue Sash and 3 strips – brown was next
Gracie jujitsu – part of the kung fu (just different instructor)
Shotokan = Purple Belt and 3 strips
Tae Kwon Do G= Green Belt
Tang Soo do = Orange Belt
Boxing (used practice with a friend who retired from pro-circuit)
Competed in college and placed first in 1997 CT state WTF state championship in my weight class.